When trying to persuade people to think and act differently, we study their wants and needs, what they care about, what keeps them up at night. Sometimes we reach them by making clear, concise arguments that address those concerns. But often it takes a little something more to engage an audience.
Presentation metaphors can help by tapping what learning theorists call prior knowledge to make a connection between what people already understand through experience and what they have yet to discover. We do this naturally in conversation — for instance, “The news hit her like a freight train.” By comparing the situation to something people already know or can at least imagine, we convey its intensity and urgency. But when explaining our ideas in presentations, we’re sometimes reluctant to use verbal or visual metaphors to relate to audiences. I’ve heard people say that metaphors are “off topic,” or worse, “cheap.” Though using a cheesy one can elicit groans, more often than not, presentation metaphors offer a shortcut to understanding.
But how do you pick the right one? By digging into your own prior knowledge for connections that make the big idea brighter in your mind. The brighter that idea shines for you, the more likely it is to resonate with your audience.
To do that effectively, get back to basics. Many of us sit in front of a computer screen all day, but studies have shown that writing by hand activates a different part of the brain and may even improve idea composition and expression. So, while you’re searching for the perfect presentation metaphors to access the full depth of someone’s prior knowledge, put your ideas down on paper — the old-fashioned way.
Very few people, if any, can come up with brilliant presentation metaphors on the first try. When we’re brainstorming in our shop, we write down the obvious choices right away just to get them out of our brains. After pushing past those, we’ll start to come up with more creative ideas. If we’re trying to illustrate partnership, we might begin with a cliché like a handshake in front of a globe but then move on to a reef ecosystem, for instance, or a photo of Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers.
If you’re feeling stuck, start naming random objects and then try to make a connection between those and your concept. This simple exercise might not lead to the metaphor, but it will jumpstart your brain.
Once you’ve generated some really good options, you’ll be tempted to stop. Don’t. Keep pushing past your creative blocks and into seemingly unrelated territory. The more unusual the presentation metaphors, the better it will stand out in people’s minds. Our associate creative director says that the first good idea comes an hour into the brainstorm. Though you might not have to brainstorm for a full hour, the point is to reach beyond your first idea — or your seventh. And don’t start filtering out options until you’ve got a critical mass to work with.
Are presentation metaphors really worth that much effort? I’d answer that question with another: How important is it for your audience to understand and embrace your idea?
Illustrated by Jamie Smetkowski